Stunning illusion

31

@jonmsutton brought this to my attention ….. the top and bottom parts of the shape are the same shade and colour…. if you don’t believe me, cover up the line between them….
illusion

31 comments on “Stunning illusion

  1. Anonymous says:

    i don’t believe you!

    • Bert says:

      Me neither. I covered up the middle as instructed, along with the ground + sky, and the lower half is a distinctly lighter colour.

    • One Eyed Jack says:

      Bert,

      You may find this version of the illusion helpful in seeing the two surfaces are the same.

    • Stevie says:

      This was shared by Richard on Facebook last week and it did work there but I agree that the lower half is slightly lighter. Certainly a lot closer than they first appear but not the same.

    • Stevie says:

      Just had a thunk! I cut two holes out of a piece of card so that I could only view the middle of both the lower and upper sections with no interference from any of the background whatsoever.
      It certainly makes a difference and it is hard to tell the two shades apart. They may actually be exactly the same!🙂

    • Nick says:

      An image editing package will tell you they’re the same. E.g. to view the image in Windows Paint, right click on the image in the web browser, choose Copy, open Paint, choose Paste. You can then find a dropper tool (in Paint this looks like an eye dropper) to sample the colour in the centre of the top piece. Pressing Edit Colors will then show you the Red, Green and Blue values for the sampled colour. Repeat this for the top piece any you’ll see that both pieces have the same R,G,B values of 123, 124, 126, so they are the same shade and colour.

      Cheers

      Nick

  2. Stevenz says:

    Um. How does it work?

  3. Anonymous says:

    Just follow the instructions and belief will follow.

  4. Alma says:

    So weird how the brain and perception works (and can fool us!) This is an excellent example.

  5. John Green says:

    Easier if you cover the stark white top of the lower shape. Works well.

  6. Anonymous says:

    The great example of how our mind get confused!!!

  7. Fotoflex says:

    I rembered an image of a ‘Rubik’s Cube’ where some colours that appear different are actually the same. Long search, but found that that image was produced by the same company as today’s illusion! What’s more, they provide ‘masks’, so you can check if the colour or brightness is the same: http://www.lottolab.org/articles/illusionsoflight.asp

  8. David Calder says:

    I do not see the same shade and colour – they come closer but do not match.

  9. Steve Ulven says:

    Neat! It actually takes a few seconds for the bottom one to appear the same shade after covering up between them.

  10. Fotoflex says:

    Ah! Now I know where I saw that cube, on ‘Horizon, is seeing believing’; http://www.lottolab.org/articles/isseeingbelieving.asp

  11. I wonder how this affects the choice of paints when a painter is mixing the colours for a piece of art. Obviously it isn’t as simple as using a darker or lighter shade.

  12. One Eyed Jack says:

    This illusion is a bit of a cheat.

    Although the two larger surfaces are the same shade, the two objects are not 100% the same. The smaller edges that touch are shaded differently to create the illusion. If they were shaded as if they were truly illuminated from above, the the forward edge of the top square would be the same as the large face of the lower square. Since we have established that the two large faces of both objects are the same and we see that the edges are different shades than the faces, we can show that the two areas in shadow are not the same.

  13. Carl says:

    Several commenters are claiming that the lower object really is a slightly lighter shade of brown than the upper one. That just goes to show how effective this illusion is, because they are, in fact, the exact same shade: 123R, 124G, 126B. Examine the image in any photo-editing program to confirm it for yourself!

  14. Isn’t this how we make decisions about important matters in life though….based on the contrasts and the surrounding noise, story, colours?? The same being perceived differently is a natural part of human unconsciousness!! A ringing bell in the dead of night vs in the midst of rush hour?? 12degrees in winter(or north pole) = warm, in summer( or equator = cold!

  15. Anonymous says:

    I didn’t believe it either, even after covering. But I downloaded the PNG and opened it in Paint Shop and the color values were all the same.

  16. Mike says:

    Cunning, maybe. But stunning? I don’t think so.

  17. Jaleel Hamid says:

    Not the same. The radient is different

  18. If you have an LCD monitor, they become distinctly different depending on viewing angle.

  19. Reblogged this on Illuminutti and commented:
    I love optical illusions!

  20. […] program, we are not positive if Georgia or her stunning palm-print mini skirt will help Mercedes increase product sales for the upcoming GLA, but the […]

  21. Ronda says:

    You can’t just cover between them–you also have to get the background out of the way in order to see it.

  22. Bobby says:

    Reminds me with the “street lit” debate.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s