Answer to the Friday Puzzle….

55

coverOn Friday I posted these 2 puzzles:

How many mistakes are there in the following sentence?

“This sentance contanes one misteak’

What is the answer to the same question for this sentence….

‘Their are three misteaks in this sentence’

If you have not tried to solve them, have a go now. For everyone else the answer is after the break.

The first one contains 4 mistakes – 2 spelling/grammatical mistakes (contanes, misteak, sentence) and the fourth is that it states that it only contains 1 mistake.

The second one is tricky because it is paradoxical. It contains 2 spelling/grammatical mistakes (their, misteak) but says that it contains three. Therefore the sentence is wrong, but that would mean that it does indeed contain three mistakes, but that would make it right, which would mean that it only contains two mistakes, and so on. So, it has no answer.

Is that what you thought?

I have produced an ebook containing 101 of the previous Friday Puzzles! It is called PUZZLED and is available for the Kindle(UKhere and USA here) and on the iBookstore (UK here in the USA here). You can try 101 of the puzzles for free here.

55 comments on “Answer to the Friday Puzzle….

  1. I failed to see the paradox in the second sentence because I counted as a mistake that, number three: It did not end with a full stop, which makes the number claim correct. But then, I’m an editor by trade.

  2. tweetyaca says:

    The second sentence also lacks a full stop, so with 3 mistakes, is no puzzle at all.

  3. Roland says:

    It still depends on what you define as misteak🙂 E.g. is Their 1 error (word is wrong), or two errors? (Added an I and forgot an E)? Is Misteak 1 error (E in the wrong place), or two errors? (extra E before the E and no E after the E).

    Further, is it a spelling check, or also a check on meaning of the sentences?

    Lots of assumptions that are not made explicit

  4. The Masked Twit says:

    If someone knowingly and deliberately utters or writes a falsehood is that a mistake?

    • AndyD_OHD says:

      I agree, as the sentences were written with intentional falsehood then neither of them contain any mistakes. I think the puzzled would have to state initially that the sentences were written without the intention of falsehood.
      And what about the fact that both sentences have no period to end the sentence so neither could be called a sentence. Then there is the error in the quotation marks in text 1 too.

  5. -M- says:

    I’ve found another error in sentence 1:
    the sentence starts with ” and ends with ‘

    Got the rest as well. Including the paradox.

    • -M- says:

      Oh, and the second sentence should have been: “There are no mistakes in this sentence” Making their-there three-no misteaks-mistakes and the error that there are errors, while the sentence says it does not contain errors. (well it does, but that’s an error, because three should have been no. Who says it’s not what the writer meant to write?)

  6. Shahram says:

    also there is a mistake in answer! where are you Richard!

  7. Darren says:

    The first sentence does not say it only contains one mistake, only that it contains one mistake. It does, as well as a few others. So I say it has 3

  8. Anonymous says:

    1. “This sentance contanes one misteak’
    4 mistakes: sentance -> sentence, contanes -> contains, misteak -> mistake, lack of full stop
    2. ‘Their are three misteaks in this sentence’
    3 mistakes: Their -> There, misteaks -> mistakes, lack of full stop

    • Stevie says:

      I was starting to wonder if anyone else saw the four mistakes in the first sentAnce.
      I thought it couldn’t just be me.

  9. 1. “This sentance contanes one misteak’

    4 mistakes: sentance -> sentence, contanes -> contains, misteak -> mistake, lack of full stop

    2. ‘Their are three misteaks in this sentence’

    3 mistakes: Their -> there, misteaks -> mistakes, lack of full stop

    is this really a puzzle?

  10. Anders says:

    I say the truth value of the sentence is nonexistant, since the sentence as written is meaningless. to say that “This sentance contanes one misteak” should be read as “This sentence contains one mistake” and that this then is a fourth mistake is incorrect in my opinion. that is not what it says, it uses undefined wordsand if we have to interpret the sentence to get a truth value from it, we could just as well define the words so the interpreted version is true

  11. Actually, the second one is not paradoxical, just false. It contains three mistakes, while claiming to contain thirteen (the third mistake is that you misspelled “thirteen” as “three”.)
    Or maybe it’s true, and the third word misspelled “two”. Or maybe you misspelled “page” as “sentence”, and there are actually thirteen after all.

  12. NickC says:

    Actually there are no ‘mistakes’ in either sentence as ‘misteak’ is spelled wrong in both

  13. Conor Maguire says:

    The first sentence contained another mistake – “This sentance contanes one misteak’
    There are double inverted commas at the start and single at the end!

  14. Anonymous says:

    Since you intended to spell those words in that way, you made no mistakes at all!

  15. Kami Arzani says:

    Your first sentence has actually four mistakes.
    “Sentence” is misspelled.

  16. Berhard says:

    the first sentence contains the term “misteak” once, so it contains one “misteak” whatever this means, and a few typoos…
    The second only contains the term “misteaks” once, so it is obviously wrong… and also may have a typo…
    I don’t know form wich animal the “Mi” steaks are cut from….

  17. Lazy T says:

    Meefinks thrs no mistks, tsaall dellybur8

  18. Hunter says:

    What about punctuation?

  19. Thicko says:

    No full stops. If you’re going to try to be clever, at least get it right….

  20. Elaine McCarthy says:

    If you count the lack of a period at the end of each sentence as a mistake, which it IS, the answer is different.

  21. Anonymous says:

    Ouch! Not really a puzzle or an illusion.

  22. Will the Thrill says:

    If you specifically intended to write the original sentences/clauses with typographical or grammatical errors, then I would contend that there are no “mistakes” at all since they look as you intended them to look.

    The definition of “mistake” implies that such an action is not intentional, that it is caused either by lack of knowledge or incorrect reasoning.

  23. Dharmaruci says:

    the num of mistakes in a sentance is surely the number of changes i has to make to make it have no mistakes. thusly.

    “This sentance contanes one misteak’

    1 change – the quote at the end
    “This sentance contanes one misteak”

    2 change – the spelling of mistake
    “This sentance contanes one mistake”

    3 change – the spelling of contains
    “This sentance contains one mistake”

    the sentence is now correct expect for the no of mistakes. so finally

    4 change – the number of mistakes
    “This sentance contains no mistake”

    Thereforely it must of contained FOUR mistakes.

  24. Mark_D says:

    I thought there were five mistakes in the first and four in the second.

    In the first, I also considered the unmatched quotes and not ending with a punctuation mark to be mistakes.

    In the second, not ending in a punctuation mark was also a mistake.

  25. One Eyed Jack says:

    Whet I fimd interstng is tnat eyrvone cen reid tnis weth no praplem.

    Spelling and grammar are overrated.

    • Berhard says:

      No, once someone died afer the message “hang him, not amnestied” has been received…,
      tragically the message sent was “hang him not, amnestied” …

  26. Jack says:

    This was a fine puzzle, and no misteak.

  27. Dave's Neighbour says:

    As they say in Ireland ….

    Whale oil beef hooked

  28. Stephen Fossler says:

    Richard,I counted 6.3 spelling- sentance, contanes, misteak.The subject of the sentance is incorrect- It has more than 1 mistake.The last set of quotation marks is missing a “hash” mark. What am I missing?

    Thank you,

    Stephen Fossler

    Date: Mon, 18 Feb 2013 07:30:47 +0000 To: stephenfossler@hotmail.com

  29. Zach says:

    The wording of your questions – “in the following sentence” – doesn’t necessitate that the sentence be accurate in its meaning, only in its grammar.

  30. Ronda says:

    No. I counted six in the first sentence–three spelling errors, the inconsistent quotation marks, the fact that it has no end punctuation, and of course the content was incorrect.

    The second one also had no end punctuation, so it actually did have three mistakes.

    I’m going to have to respectfully disagree with this one, Richard. NOT a good puzzle, at least not with those answers!

  31. I like steak says:

    humph! I counted no mistakes in either sentence – they only contain ‘misteaks’. trying to be too smart Alec I think🙂

  32. I like this kind of puzzle, but these two are confusing. First of all, Nick C. is correct. The answers could well be that there are no mistakes in either as the word “mistake” is misspelled in both sentences. BUT, that’s not Richard’s answer. And what are those quotation marks, internal quotation marks and mismatched quotation marks doing there any way? Richard accepts them as correct, it seems. And Richard, are you saying that sentance, contanes and misteak in the first sentence are not THREE spelling mistakes? I could go on.

  33. decourse says:

    I count only one mistake in second sentence. The word “this” should read “that”.

  34. Will says:

    There were no mistakes. The misspellings and untruthful statements were quite deliberate. How’s that for nitpicking it?

  35. ctj says:

    “This sentance contanes one misteak’
    (1) “sentance”
    (2) “contanes”
    (3) “misteak”
    (4) mismatched quotation marks
    (5) not one mistake

    What is the answer to the same question for this sentence….
    (1) no question mark
    (2) four ellipses (although this could be viewed as the same error)

    i thought the trick was that the first question specified the “following sentence” while the second specified “this sentence.”

  36. Sandy Tabor says:

    What about the quotation marks in the first sentence and lack of a period in both?

  37. Somebody's mom's neighbor's neighbor says:

    Nooooo! I found 6 in the first one. No period. A single quote paired with a double quote. And either that it was inaccurate, or, or, something else I forgot.

  38. Chris says:

    The 2nd contains 3 mistakes, “their”, “misteaks”, and the lack of a period at the end. The message is correct.

    • Chris says:

      Also, the first has 5 mistakes: “sentance”, “contanes”, “misteaks”, no period, and the meanin of the sentance is inaccurate.

  39. Donald says:

    Also, the open and close quotes don’t match – which would be a mistake. (or 2) …now 3…now 4…

  40. Lothar says:

    Also, I think that it is a mistake to say that there is no answer to the second one. The correct term is that the truth is indeterminate, but that is an answer.
    Kinda like whether God answers all prayers and someone will say that sometimes the answer is “no.” I accept, but while “yes” is an answer, “no” is an answer, and even “I’m not going to give you an answer” is an answer; “” is NOT an answer.

  41. Robena says:

    Although I really don’t concur along with you, I locate your shipping of one’s viewpoint one which I can really come across nice to hear to.My encounters with science and character have definitely been diverse.I seriously admire your considering.I ought to consider an opposing see on “vulcanism”, on the other hand. Being a quite untypical girl, I have been advised I’m exceptionally reasonable and analytical. And, much like the typical girl, I have triggers that make me cry, but it surely could possibly make you chortle.I uncover myself most discouraged and pushed into tears by people today behaving illogically. I ultimately had a boyfriend examine me and say, “That’s just it. Individuals will not make feeling mainly. You have to cease anticipating them to, and after that you will be significantly less annoyed significantly less usually.”Just imagined you can obtain a giggle from me.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s