Can you solve this mystery?

63

First, for those of you in or around the Stirling area, I am giving the John Damien Lecture at the University of Stirling tonight.  Details here.

OK, so a few days ago someone sent me this photograph of the Spanish minister Carme Chacón….

The odd thing is that the toes on her legs appear reversed.  Can you solve the mystery?

 

63 comments on “Can you solve this mystery?

  1. Zaid says:

    She crossed her legs?

  2. Rob says:

    Simple. She doesn’t actually have her legs crossed. Her left arm is covering the top of her left thigh, making it looks like her legs are crossed, but they aren’t.

    • Mike Hitchcock says:

      Ha! I saw they were crossed at the ankles, but didn’t see the illusion that they were crossed at her knees until you pointed it out.

    • Bob O'H says:

      So how does her left thigh go under her left knee?

      What’s really going is that she’s an amputee and she took off her spare left leg.

    • Dee says:

      @Bob: It’s not, it’s behind it with the knee covered up by her arm.

  3. Mike Hitchcock says:

    What mystery? She has her legs crossed….

  4. Bored Wombat says:

    Her legs aren’t crossed at the knee, only the ankle. The line of her sleeve looks to be the top of her leg, but it isn’t.

  5. Anonymous says:

    It’s amazing what you can do with Photoshop…

  6. Chris says:

    It’s amazing what you can do with Photoshop…

  7. Damocles says:

    Yeah, clearly crossed legs.

  8. Chrissie says:

    That is weird! Couldn’t see it at first cos was looking at her feet but when you follow the legs up it is odd. Will have to stare again! Any excuse??

  9. Vinod says:

    her legs are uncrossed..

  10. Vinod says:

    check out the thumbs on her hand and you can see her legs arent crossed..

  11. Martin Smith says:

    The optical illusion is caused by her left arm. At first glance it seems like she has her legs crossed when in fact she is merely sitting in the same position that a lady who was riding a horse sidesaddle would adopt.

  12. Here’s someone who did some retouching, admittedly poorly, that shows what’s really going on under her hand.

    http://www.moillusions.com/2011/09/photoshop-fail-or-optical-illusion.html

  13. Does the minister really wear such a short skirt – or is the illusion that the skirt is two coloured with the lower one flesh coloured – her legs are not crossed

  14. Steve Jones says:

    Short of some bad Photoshop work (for examples see photoshopdisasters.com), we have to work out why her logs appear crossed, which is what would make the toes seem reversed.

    The impression that the legs are crossed is caused by her arm masking the upper half of her left leg and the shadow from that, and the crossed-over right hand (the lighting is from the right of the picture as can be seen from shadows). Remove that effect, and she should be revealed as sitting straight with her right leg crossing behind her left only at the ankle.

    (and why don’t we have glamorous ministers in the UK?).

  15. Peter Leeson says:

    Why are all these people staring at a respectable politician’s legs?

  16. Mad Kev says:

    I would vote yes.

  17. Imchinese says:

    just cover up the seemingly exposed thigh with ur fingersthen u’ll find the answer: indeed she didn’t cross her thigh at all.

  18. CAPER says:

    Her toes are connected to her feet; her feet are connected to her legs.

    She has her lovely legs crossed at the ankle level…

  19. Bob says:

    Wow, that was a quick mind job.

  20. Cynthia says:

    I think her dress was originally longer

  21. Skip says:

    Maybe I need my eyes checked; I can’t see anything resembling an illusion at all. Legs are crossed at roughly shin-height, right leg behind the left leg.

  22. RichT says:

    This was on photoshopdisasters.com a few days ago…

  23. Anonymous says:

    Her dress is not as short as it first appears. There is a thick horizontal flesh coloured stripe at the base…?

  24. Omar S says:

    This pic was very famous in Spain a week ago, it has SO MUCH photoshop, they actually switch legs unfortunately baaaad

  25. species77 says:

    Her legs are not crossed. The illusion comes from the shadow from her left arm.

  26. Anonymous says:

    it’s funny all these people screaming “Photoshop!” cant take a minute to actually scrutinize the photo and see it’s not retouched at all!

  27. Lucas says:

    There is a puppet face (like Saw’s Jigsaw) on the reflection of the window.

  28. Trevor says:

    Her leg is just up with her hand and forearm covering her knee and upper thigh. So what you see is the line created where the back of her thigh and the back of her calf meet. We ASSUME it signifies her legs are crossed, but that’s an assumption our brains make.
    You can easily recreate this at home. There is absolutely NO photo manipulation of any kind involved.

  29. kathy says:

    Her feet are so big and her shoes so ugly that no one notices her legs aren’t crossed.

  30. Stu says:

    The fact that her sleeve covering her left thigh is closely aligned with the top of her right knee leads our brain to connect the dots. Seeing may be believing, but you shouldn’t always believe what you see.

  31. Anonymous says:

    she has no left thigh,but damn good looking legs !

  32. Shane says:

    There is a creepy face in the window

  33. Anonymous says:

    Her tan purse is near her left thigh

  34. Gabriel says:

    Her torso also seems completely misaligned with her butt. Photoshop for the insecure politician.

  35. Doug says:

    She was involved in a horrible skiing accident years ago. Tore her legs right off. Very tragic. Only way doctors could save her legs was to swap them.

  36. Frank says:

    Who cares about her toes !

  37. Wingfoil says:

    Simple, the flesh coloured thigh you see below her hands is not actually thigh, but a coloured band on the bottom of her dress

  38. Anonymous says:

    Never mind that – how has no one noticed it’s Philippa Forrester of off children’s’ TV?

  39. Anonymous says:

    The shadow of her right hand is creating this confusion. That’s all.
    Thanks

    • fib says:

      Dang – you beat me to it! lol. It’s just the shadow of the fingers of her right hand that’s dangling down. Simples🙂

  40. Lancelot says:

    I have the answer : she is the secret daughter of this woman :

    http://bendrole.com/image-illusion-commentaires.php?t=Une+femme+avec+un+pied+en+place+d'une+main

    🙂

  41. Anonymous says:

    Did anyone realized a creepy face right up on that womans’s head?(ow,and I actually believe that she made a very curious illusion)..

  42. Anonymous says:

    it’s definitely potoshop, impossible to get such a position of the legs

  43. katie k says:

    I don’t understand, they don’t look reversed to me. That’s exactly how I’d expect her toes to be in that position.

  44. Santiago says:

    I find it somewhat incredible that most people assume it’s an optical illusion when the simplest explanation is some sort of photoshop mistake.

    There is strong evidence this photo has been shopped (besides the toes, I mean): look at the edge where her left leg goes over her right. You’ll notice this edge looks “soft”, or out of focus. Exactly what one would expect the result to be of a blend or smooth command or similar in an editing programme.

  45. not possible.. I really think it’s Photoshopped. But I think the key is the left hand covering her kneecap.

  46. adorita says:

    Just another Photoshop disaster.

  47. S says:

    Took me a while, but yes, it’s not crossed at the knee, the positioning of her legs and hand makes it look as if it is, but her knees are the right way round and the cross only appears at the ankle. Tough to see though, even though I’m 99% sure of the answer, I can still see a second crossing… might have to use my wife a guinea pig to test this.

  48. alex says:

    The photo was taken in front of a mirror.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s