Join in with the battle of clever stuff!

92

Last week I staged another battle of the clever stuff, and put a nice illusion photograph against an optical illusion. The optical illusion won by a narrow margin. So, it stays on, and this week it is up against a wonderful poster. Have a look at them both….here is the illusion again (the squares make complete circles)….

3qiYJ

And here is a wonderful poster for HBO’s vampire show, True Blood (look at it and the hidden image will suddenly appear – after which you will not be able to see it any other way)

true-blood-season-2-poster

This, of course, is a modern version of the ‘what can you see in the image below’ illusion….

cow420

So, which wins?Illusion or poster?  Vote now and feel free to justify your choice below….

92 comments on “Join in with the battle of clever stuff!

  1. Aly says:

    If the blood puddle were actually shaped like something else, it would be cooler. I went for the optical illusion.

  2. Ania says:

    You can see the poster either way quite easily

  3. Raja says:

    Is it a woman with open mouth in the vampire poster?

  4. cam says:

    I prefer the vampire one.

  5. Briantist says:

    The vampire poster is two profiles, one at the top and the bottom one with biting the upper one’s neck.

    Guess it’s not that good if people can’t see it.

  6. orinoco says:

    What are we supposed to see in the very bottom picture? Looks to me like part of a disfigured face, but if that’s what it’s supposed to be it’s a bit crap.

    • Ana says:

      Not sure whether this is what we are supposed to see but I can see the head of a cow on the left

    • Bucket says:

      it is a cow, but i couldn’t figure out what the hell it was util I put my cursor over it and it said ‘cow420′ or something to that effect. Then I saw it right away.

  7. Will says:

    Wow the vampire one is amazing, took me quite a while to see it. But that is awesome, i kept seeing a profile in the top right which is wrong, eventually i saw it though. Two profiles, one about to bite the other ones neck.

  8. orinoco says:

    Aha! The very bottom one is a cow! Moo!

  9. shuwaka says:

    is there a caw in the bottom picture?

  10. Raja says:

    I see it too in the vampire picture now. It is amazing!! :D

  11. orinoco says:

    Thanks Ana, just saw it before I saw your reply :)

  12. orinoco says:

    Kind of want to vote for the cow now. :(

  13. Took me a while to see the vampire poster properly, but now I can see it it is my fav! Still don’t get first the optical illusion :/

    • James says:

      The optical illusion looks like a spiral going down towards the middle. But it is not actually a spiral. Run your finger along the “path” of the circles and you will see that they are four perfect circles, none of them are spiral shaped, none of them join up and none of them cross the other circles, but the impression is that it somehow is a spiral.

  14. The Poster is good but the Optical illusion is better.

  15. I voted for the vampire poster. It took me a little while to see it but when it appeared I thought Wow! that’s brilliant.

    I can see a cow in the bottom picture.

  16. Sally says:

    Chose the optical illusion – so effective.
    In the bottom image, I first saw a strange-looking face with stitches on one cheek, then saw a hybrid cow/pig.

  17. alocaly says:

    is there really something on the last image ?
    Or is it just a trap to make us imagine ‘things’ from a strange image ?
    Is it a kind of Rorschach test ?

  18. Garrett says:

    I remember seeing the bottom picture in a psych class in college. It’s meant to show you that if you don’t know what it is your brain looks at it a lot of different ways trying to figure it out. Then when you are shown, and know what it is you can’t see it in any other way than what the picture is actually showing.

    the picture above is of a cow looking at you. Large black spot on the left side is an ear, just bellow that to the right is an eye. Going straight to the right is the other eye and ear with the nose at the bottom between the two.

    • qbsmd says:

      Thank you for that; I wouldn’t have been able to find the cow without that. I saw the cow’s neck as teeth, and was trying to find a face from there.

    • Erin says:

      Like qbsmd, even after learning there was a cow in the picture, I couldn’t see it until your description. Thank you!

  19. shannon says:

    I love the visual images and not so much the optical illusion. I’ve always liked visually arresting images and it amazes me how long it takes me to see the images. Over a minute for each. The Vampire poster popped into my brain suddenly and the cow slowly faded in. The brain is such an interesting thing.

  20. Gus Snarp says:

    Yeah, I never would have found the cow without you describing it, Garret.

    I vote poster, just to keep things changing. Also, it’s artistic whereas the illusion is really just math. Not that there’s anything wrong with math.

  21. Nicola says:

    I voted for the optical illusion (again). Can you put something in there that beats it please?! Also, am i the only one who saw a deer’s face in the B&W picture?

  22. zooterkin says:

    I couldn’t ‘get’ the third image until I saw the filename, and then it was obvious.

    The poster is clever, but I agree with the other comments, you can still see it both ways after seeing the hidden image.

    The circles of squares still make my brain hurt.

  23. kiran says:

    teh vampire poster is pretty neat – biting a neck fits in very well with the vampire theme! but i rather liked the optical illusion – yes the squares do make full circles if u look closely.

  24. Dan says:

    The optical illusion is clever, but I liked the vampire one better. I didn’t see a cow until I read the comments. I saw a skull, Stalin’s moustache, smoke, and winter trees.

  25. Bucket says:

    I pick the cow.
    I only saw the two people in the vampire picture, it wasn’t hard at all, and the circles make my head hurt.

  26. Steve says:

    I can see 3 different images in the vampire poster: 1) an archipelago, 2) dripping blood 3) human and vampire. If I concentrate, I can shift my perspective to see the one I want.

    …but I like the top one better.

  27. [...] friends like psychologist Richard Wiseman: I see all kinds of things I never would have otherwise. On his blog Richard posted one of the best optical illusions I have ever [...]

  28. Nikki says:

    I couldn’t see anything BUT the vampire and the prey in the True Blood picture though I assumed I was supposed to see a pool of blood as well. Took a while and then I saw that. Sort of.
    I love the spirals, that illusion hurts my eyes to look at but if you follow the circles with your mouse you can straighten it out a bit.
    The first one is my favourite.

  29. fluffy says:

    I was introduced to the cow picture in a human-computer interaction class, in a lecture to demonstrate how just because something is clear to you (because you understand it) doesn’t mean it’s clear to anyone else.

    I still see the cow and can’t un-see it. Thanks. Dr. Ogden!

  30. chloe says:

    The vampire poster wins hands down.
    I couldn’t see ANYTHING in the optical illusion ’til I followed Garrett’s instructions to start at the left ear. Thanks Garrett for saving my sanity!

  31. [...] friends like psychologist Richard Wiseman: I see all kinds of things I never would have otherwise. On his blog Richard posted one of the best optical illusions I have ever [...]

  32. Alex says:

    It took me forever to see the vampires, but I’m also viewing it on a little screen which probably doen’t help. I saw the cow right away.

  33. croint says:

    If you’re a participant in the “420” ritual, then perceiving the cow head becomes easier… or not.

  34. Chris says:

    Wow it took me forever to see the cow, even when I knew it was there. Tilting my head 90* to the right helped. What is that cross-hatched pattern at the lower left? It’s not part of the cow. And where’s the rest of the cow? It’s not really fair! :)

    • chloe says:

      i think the hatched pattern is a fence?! (behind the cow). it’s body is to the right of the pic. it’s standing side on – with it’s head twisted to its left.

  35. Ashley says:

    i saw the vampires and the cow right away. I didn’t get the last pic because i thought there would be something more that the cow

  36. Lyvvie says:

    Took me forever to figure the last one and in the end I lost patience and had to peek at comments and cheat. I love the circle-square illusion!

  37. Whilst I liked the vampire, once seen that is all I can see now. So, from the perspective of throwing my eyes into total confusion (or my brain) I voted for the optical illusion. Even knowing that they are concentric circles, my brain and eyes refuse to see them that way.

  38. Skjæve says:

    I don’t get the third picture. It’s blurry, grained, scratched and saturated picture. It’s also obviously a cow. What’s the deal?

    • Ann says:

      Just saw this post. In the “cow” picture, my husband saw a skull and I saw two cats, one in a cage. We couldn’t see the cow until we read through the comments. So, it’s not obvious to everyone.

  39. wourm says:

    Problem with the vampire poster is that the red doesn’t look much like blood. I focussed first on the profiles then realized that the red was supposed to be blood.

  40. [...] Richard Wiseman via Phil Plait’s Bad Astronomy comes this image of squares arranged in concentric [...]

  41. MadScientist says:

    I loved the square/circle/spiral illusion so I made a PostScript version of it. :) Anyone want the code to tinker with?

  42. Berber Anna says:

    Just figured out something interesting — if I look at the circles illusion while scrolling the page (so when it’s moving), it actually looks like circles. As soon as I stop scrolling, it looks like spirals again. Wonder how that works?

  43. Michael Swanson says:

    I keep wondering if I’m supposed to see something other than a cow’s face in the bottom picture, because I saw her the moment I looked at the picture. It seems very clear: this is a cow. Is there something else there?

  44. nev says:

    I can only see Rorschach inkblots

  45. [...] Join in with the battle of clever stuff! Last week I staged another battle of the clever stuff, and put a nice illusion photograph against an optical illusion. [...] [...]

  46. CDarcy says:

    All I see is the Isthmus of Panama in the bottom pic. Seriously, I don’t see anything else.

    • brian says:

      I saw a degraded map at first, and then i squinted for a while and looked at it through one eye and finally made out the cow. now the cow is obvious, but i still see the map also

  47. RT says:

    For those that saw a cow in the bottom picture right away, Im curious if maybe youve seen this image before. Im no idiot and Ive seen a TON of illusions, including the similiar dalamation one.. However I saw nothing but maybe human teeth in xray (The black spots to the left of the nostrils) until someone described how the cows head was situated.

    I still feel a bit lied to, because those “teeth” and any blobs outside the cows head-area seem like random inkblobs added to confuse the viewer. Even once you seen the cows head, all those blobs outside the head look like… well, blobs.

    Perhaps the “xray teeth” im seeing to the left of the nostrils are because the cow is leaning over a barbed wire fence? Otherwise, I see nothing but confusion outside of the Inner-head image.

  48. ArcLight says:

    I don’t think I’ve seen it before but I looked at the picture of the cow for a minute or so trying to figure out what else was supposed to be there before reading the comments.

  49. Atonnis says:

    I saw the vampires instantly, and saw the blood puddle third. The second thing I saw was a man facing to the left made out of the ‘blood puddle’ (he has a hat on). I thought that was the illusion until I read the comments.

    The third image I saw a cat and a gerbil/mouse-like thing, which shifted into a feeding bird from above, and includes a lined partial image of the globe on the left, and it keeps shifting around. The cow is in there, but it seems one of the weaker images.

    So my winner is the illusion. I knew immediately was the illusion was, but it taxes two eyes to follow the ‘lines’. I close one eye and can follow it easily.

  50. Walt Disney says:

    I see a Hidden Mickey.

  51. [...] one from Wiseman will certainly take your mind for a ride. Spirals or [...]

  52. MadScientist says:

    OK, I finally see the cow; I was wondering what the hell people were babbling about. Why does the cow have a grid pattern on it? how about the bunny – anyone else see the bunny? I’ts not very realistic, more like a hand shadow but in the negative.

    • chloe says:

      bunny? you’ve lost me there.
      it looks like there’s a grid because the cow is standing infront of a gate or a fence

  53. Morienos says:

    Optical illusions are the drug of people recruiting psychologists. Most 1st year text books have lots of them in them. They’re like the candy man from Chitty Chitty Bang Bang

    Then you study it for a decade and go

    “hold on, no one mentioned SPSS”

  54. Edgewise says:

    I see a vampire cow! Walking in a spiral!

  55. cow says:

    ITS A COW!

  56. In my communication class in college, I presented the class with around 25 various illusion prints from a collection my psychology instructor maintained in the college library. Every classmate enjoyed this viewing and many said it make you realize things are not always as they appear to be.
    If you enjoyed these shots, you should take the time to search out others. It makes a nice hobby and sharing what you find with friends makes for great time sharing. It will make you look at the things you see around you and notice there are actually a lot of strange patterns everywhere.
    Good job and I hope you continue to find more views to share with everyone. These type of views are worth sharing.

  57. Alvin says:

    Hey I posted this comment on Phil Plait’s blog but thought it would be good to blatantly self-promote research here too :)

    Here’s the same illusion with more squares and rings

    Tilting the squares in every other ring by 90 degrees actually changes the illusion from this weird intersectiony thing into a spiraly illusion

    This particular illusion was created by Pinna and Gregory in 2002, and our lab recently did some research on it!

    And we can make it more dramatic by filtering the image a little:

    Here’s an animation I created going between the intersecting-circles illusion to the spiral illusion, the motion is very subtle but your perception of the two illusions switching is pretty dramatic

    There is no effect when all the squares are the same color

    the background color of the image actually makes a difference. The effect only appears when the background luminance is between the two colors of the squares.

    We actually have recently submitted an abstract to VSS that explains (most) of this illusion as a by-product of how we represent visual information. And we can even make images that are guesses of the perception of the illusion using that representation:

    (note the spirally-ness or the intertwinyness)

    and for a control:

    poster download with more details is here: http://people.csail.mit.edu/alvin/pinna/pinna_v7.pdf

  58. GABRIEL says:

    I see the vampires and the cow right away-…and look and look, and still see only that.

    In the vampire one, what else are we supposed to be able to see?

  59. Karen says:

    I couldn’t see the vampire/woman image until it was explained to me, and now I can’t un-see it… but I still can’t see the cow :(

  60. Mahkno says:

    Very angry dog on the last picture

  61. Pepijn says:

    Am I the only one for whom the boxes / circles optical illusion looks distorted? I’m only seeing the left half, stretched horizontally to fill the complete width, with alternating white lines between. It looks like that in Firefox and in IE, and even in Irfanview if I download it. But I definitely remember seeing it correctly a few days ago!

  62. jean paul miro says:

    I’m a designer in new york and the True Blood poster I saw in a bus shelter and for a while I couldnt understand what it was, days later came by it again and finally understood the picture, after that just like the arrow in the fedex logo I havent been able to see anything else but the revelation. The optical illusion though, thats a great one!

  63. DimlyAware says:

    The cool thing about the circle of squares illusion is that it appears to rotate when you scroll up or down. Very Nice.

  64. woof105 says:

    It’s been a long time since I studied Geometry however I believe that the principle still exists today as it did when I was a boy and that is 1. A square is a square. It has four sides of which all are equal. 2. A circle consists of one line commencing at one point and continuing through 360 Degrees to link up with the point of origin. Which can then be divided into a. It’s Diameter and b. It’s total size being it’s circumfrence. It is impossible to link together a number of squares to create a circle. If that was the case then a circle would not be a circle. Point in case: With a “Compass” either “Magnetic” or “Gyroscopic”, both work on the principle that both regard the circle as being the “Whole” and as such, is then divided into 1. four equal 1/4s 2. each of those 1/4s are then divided by a further 4 x 1/4s then each quarter is again divided by 4 again. Finally the circle (Completus Maximus) is devided into (At the lowest Common Demonitor) 360 x 1Degree points. The first 4 Points are North, South, East and West. Dividing each of these by 4 one gets a division of each by 4 and they are 1. North North East 2. North East 3. East North East 4. East. ie: 22.5 Degrees of the circle at each given point. Multiply 22.5 x 16 and you should arrive with ?

    So if what I have attempted to extrapolate here is indeed correct then it would be impossible to group a number of squares together to form a circle.

    Regards woof105.

  65. Diana Salha says:

    personally, i can see so many things in the last picture. however, no cow is clear to my eyes.
    It took me a while to see the vampire picture. It has two profiles, a face trying to bite the neck of the other.. and there is blood in between.
    And i can not understand the circles/ squares debate. What should/ shouldn’t I see?

  66. easy piano says:

    easy piano…

    [...] Good piano performance. Thanks heaps for this!… if anyone else has anything it would be much appreciated. Great website http://www.en.Grand-Pianos.org Enjoy!…

  67. [...] RichardWiseMan Leer más: drama, Fichajes, Grant Bowler, HBO, Personajes, theo alexander, True Blood, Vampiros [...]

  68. [...] Ale fajnie jest obserwować jak nasz wzrok próbuje tam znaleźć tyle innych kształtów ;) Źródło Niby tylko jeden kwadrat we wnętrzu drugiego a tyle zabawy ;) Źródło Skup się na kropkach i [...]

  69. amy says:

    Does anyone know where the photo of the cow originated from? Who took it when?

  70. [...] gracias a que nuestro cerebro se puede “sugestionar” mediante la vista. [ Vía - Richard Wiseman's Blog y visto en Bad Astronomy]. Publicado el 21 agosto, 2009 por admin. Esta entrada fué publicada en [...]

  71. [...] το βρήκα στο discovermagazine που με τη σειρά του το βρήκε στο richardwiseman, όπου υπάρχουν άλλα δύο αντικείμενα οφθαλμαπάτης. Το 3ο [...]

  72. Anonymous says:

    I don’t get the third image. could anyone tell me?

  73. Hmm is anyone else encountering problems with the pictures on this blog loading?
    I’m trying to find out if its a problem on my end or if it’s the blog.
    Any responses would be greatly appreciated.

  74. Have you ever thought about adding a little bit more than just your articles?

    I mean, what you say is valuable and everything. But think of
    if you added some great photos or video clips to give your posts more, “pop”!
    Your content is excellent but with images and video clips, this site could certainly be one of the best in its
    field. Wonderful blog!

  75. Thankfulness to my father who shared with me concerning this blog, this webpage is truly amazing.

  76. Oh my goodness! Incredible article dude! Thank you so much,
    However I am having difficulties with your RSS. I don’t understand the reason why I cannot subscribe to it.
    Is there anybody having similar RSS issues?
    Anyone that knows the answer can you kindly respond?
    Thanks!!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s